COMPARISON GUIDE
1. Asphalt Shingles
Cost : Inexpensive
Durability : 12 - 25 Years
Minimum Slope : 2 in 12
Advantages : Easy Installation ; Available In A Variety Of Colors ; Easy To Repair ; Requires Little Maintenance.
Disadvantages : Poor Fire Resistance ; Subject To Algae And Molding In Damp Climates ; Crinkles And Curls From Excessive Sunlight Over Time.
2. Roll Roofing
Cost : Inexpensive
Durability : 10 - 15 Years
Minimum Slope : 1 in 12
Advantages : Easy Installation And Maintenance
Disadvantages : Poor Fire Resistance ; Drab Appearance
3. Wood Shingles/Shakes
Cost : Moderate To Expensive
Durability : 15 - 30 Years (Shingles) 25 - 75 Years (Shakes)
Minimum Slope : 3 in 12 ( Steeper In Humid Climates )
Advantages : Attractive Rustic Appearance ; Natural Insulator
Disadvantages : Highly Flammable Unless Specially Treated ; Shingles Must Be Installed Over Open Planks
4. Slate
Cost : Expensive
Durability : 50 - 100 Years
Minimum Slope : 4 in 12
Advantages : Attractive Traditional Appearance ; Fire Resistant
Disadvantages : Heavy ; Brittle ; Requires Sturdy Roof Support ; Long And Delicate Installation Requires Special Tools ; Needs Regular Replacement Of Damaged Pieces ; Difficult To Repair
5. Ceramic Tiles
Cost : Expensive
Durability : 50 - 100 Years
Minimum Slope : 4 in 12
Advantages : Attractive Traditional Appearance : Fire Resistant
Disadvantages : Heavy ; Brittle ; Requires Sturdy Roof Support ; Time-Consuming Installation ; Requires Special Tools ; Availability Of Certain Styles Unreliable ; Difficult To Repair
6. Metal Panels
Cost : Moderate
Durability : 25 - 50 Years
Minimum Slope : 2 in 12
Advantages : Easy Installation And Patching ; Can Be Painted ; Fire Resistant
Disadvantages : Subject To Wind Damage, Falling Trees, Extreme Contact
Use This Handy Guide When You Are Deciding To Re-roof, Knowing The Pros And Cons Will Give You the Edge When Selecting The Type Of Roof You Want To Install. Remember, Your Roof Is One Of The Most Important Components Of The Structural Framework Of Your House, And Having The Right Materials, Proper Installation, And Reputable Contractor Will Ensure The Life Of Your Roof For Many Years To Come !
![]() |
| Asphalt Shingles |






